Urban warfare and LOTR
So, I was thinking of what to do for a blog post, so I thought I would do another battle report. I didn't really feel like doing a scenario, so I made two 550 point teams to go head to head. I decided to steer away from the typical open field battleground; I decided that, instead, I would go for a city battle board. So, I pulled out some old "houses" that I made a long time ago, along with some styrofoam blocks that I made into "houses." When I ran out of styrofoam and I still had some empty space, I just threw in some kleenex boxes, leaving a central court open in the middle. Basically, it's a death match. First person to wipe out the opponent wins. Here are the forces:
Good side:
17 High elf warriors with swords.
12 High elf warriors with bows.
6 High elf warriors with shield and spear.
1 High elf captain.
1 High elf with banner.
Gil-Galad
Evil Side:
8 Morannon orcs with sword and shield.
6 Morannon orcs with spear and shield.
6 Morannon orcs with spear.
8 Mordor orcs with sword and shield.
8 Mordor orcs with spear.
4 Mordor orcs with bow.
2 Mordor Uruk-hai.
1 Mordor Troll Chieftan.
1 Orc captain.
Mouth of Sauron.
The board before the forces were deployed:The starting positions: (Good side)
(Evil side)For the first round, everyone moved forward as normally.
The second round was similarly quiet, except for the movement forward of both sides.The third round signaled the turn just before fighting was engaged. The sides moved into close range of each other.
On the fourth round, the evil side decided to stay out of combat range in most areas. The elves only managed to get into combat with the troll and several orcs. All three elves attacking the troll were killed, and two other elven archers were killed by the orcs.
Both sides clashed into full combat on the fifth round. The evil side gained priority, so they were able to choose their fights. They killed 10 elves, while the good side only took out 3 orcs, while giving the orc captain 2 wounds.
The evil side gained priority again the sixth round, and made the elves pay again by killing 6 elves with only 1 orc dying on the evil side.
The good side managed to gain priority the seventh round. They could only kill 3 orcs, while 2 elves fell in return. Gil-Galad managed to win his fight with the troll, but failed to wound. The elven captain took 2 wounds, but managed to survive with the use of his fate, as did the Mouth of Sauron.
The good side, now under 50% of their starting force, was required to take courage tests for each model before they moved. Most of them managed to pass their tests, however. Gil-Galad was not able to win his fight against the troll, and received 3 wounds, recovering one with his fate. 4 other elves were killed. Several elves teamed up to finish off the Mouth of Sauron, and one other orc died.
The elves started to re-group; since they all passed their tests, they were successful in their movement. Gil-Galad managed to give the troll one wound, while 2 other orcs and 1 elf were killed.
Most of the elves passed their courage tests again; only one orc died, and Gil-Galad was unable to wound the troll.
The evil side managed to gain priority again; they surrounded Gil-Galad, and managed to finish him off. The other elves were more fortunate, winning all of their fights and even killing one orc.
The evil side once again gained priority, managing to take down one elf. The elves were in good form once again, however, and two more orcs died.
The elves were unable to stop the tidal wave of orcs, as 3 elves fell in exchange for only one orc. With 5 elves left for the good side, things seemed impossible.
Only one elf died the next turn, while the elven captain and his one follower took down one orc.
The last two elves, isolated by themselves and faced with the troll, failed their courage tests and were cut down by the troll, leaving the elven captain and one elf alive.
The good side gained priority again, but, guess what, the elven captain failed his courage test. The orcs managed to get into combat with the lone elf warrior, but he fought them off and took one down.
The evil side gained priority and surrounded both remaining elves; the elven captain succumbed to 6 orcs and fell, along with his sidekick, leaving the evil side with an easy victory.
So, what exactly went wrong for the good side?
I think it had somewhat to do with 1/3 of the good side being archers, when there really was no opportunity for archery. If those archers had gotten off several volleys at the orcs, things could easily have gone the other way. They did manage to do some damage to the leadership of the orcs, killing the Mouth of Sauron and leaving the orc captain and troll chieftain with only 1 wound each. The orcs' strategy of mobbing the elves worked well, since the elves didn't have nearly enough spearmen to support all their swordsmen, leaving many unprotected. So, basically, the elves need to get their act together :P






